Florida Supreme Court Allows Birth Injury Lawsuit
A state supreme court ruling will allow a Florida family to sidestep a state fund and sue the hospital and doctors they allege acted in negligence and caused their daughter to suffer serious birth injuries. If their lawsuit is successful, it could have a far reaching result on doctors’ liability in situations involving birth injuries in Florida.
On September 26, 2001, following a car accident that forced her mother into labor, Tristan Bennett was born via cesarean section and required resuscitation and oxygen before being put in a special care nursery. Only days later, Tristan stopped breathing and suffered a pulmonary hemorrhage as well as other kidney and liver problems.
Follow up tests determined that Tristan had suffered serious and permanent neurological damage. The Bennett family charged that the doctors performing the birth had given Tristan too much intravenous fluid and not tested for serum electrolyte derangements following the birth.
While they wanted to pursue a lawsuit against the hospital because the injury had occurred after the post-delivery period, they first had to get permission from a judge to avoid falling under the purview of a payout from the Florida Birth-Related Neurological Injury Compensation Association.
According to the Florida Birth injury Related Neurological Injury Compensation Association’s website, the program was created in 1988 to pay medical bills for children born with “certain neurological injuries” without the need for litigation.
The fund can be used to fund “actual expenses for necessary and reasonable care, services, drugs, equipment, facilities, and travel” that do not include expenses that can be compensated by state or federal governments/private insurers, a one-time cash award of no more than $100,000 to the parents/guardians of the child, a death $10,000 death benefit for the infant, or “reasonable expenses for filing the claim, including attorney’s fees.”
Following differing rulings from a Florida administrative law judge and the state First District Court of Appeal, the Florida Supreme Court ultimately ruled on July 7 that the family could proceed with a lawsuit against the doctors and hospital who performed the birth.
The decision has led to debate among medical experts and NICA over the long-term effects of future potential lawsuits regarding birth injuries. Regardless, it is good to hear that the Bennetts will have their day in court to hold the doctors/hospital liable for their errors.
If you or a loved one have given birth to a child with a birth injury, there may be legal action worth pursuing. Speak to an birth injury attorney at Sokolove Law today to learn more about any potential lawsuits you may be able to pursue.
Birth Injury